Skip to main content

A gist of Congress’ ‘Theoretical’ GST


                                        A gist of Congress’ ‘Theoretical’ GST
The Congress election manifesto has called for a ‘single, moderate, standard rate’ of goods and services tax (GST). It might have theoretical appeal, but can hardly be a practical proposition in a large diverse economy, and could be regressive. Revenue collections under GST have reportedly added up to Rs 1.06 lakh crore for March, a credible 15.6% higher than collections in the same period last year. Yet, GST remains a work-in-progress. The two middle rates of 12% and 18% probably could be compressed and lowered, and the peak rate of 28% axed.
The Congress manifesto promises to bring real estate, petroleum products, tobacco and liquor under the ambit of GST within two years, and adds that there would be a special rate of duty on demerit goods, which is unexceptionable. It does make perfect sense to extend GST to the entire real estate sector, and not limit it to under-construction housing, for tax efficiency and transparency. But the taxable event under GST is simply the supply of goods and services, and real estate is neither defined as a good nor a service in the GST Act, so a constitutional amendment is required, as in the case of alcohol. The manifesto makes no mention of subsuming electricity duty under GST. But it is essential to do so, to step up much-needed efficiency in power distribution, with set-offs available along the value chain for the tax levied. Over Rs 30,000 crore accrue to states annually on account of electricity duty, and distort incentives to arrest revenue leakage in distribution.
Some petroleum products like LPG are included in GST. But the main oil products are not, with inbuilt provision for cascading tax-on-tax across the value chain that nets over Rs 5 lakh crore revenue. The way ahead is to have GST that provides only limited set-offs for oil products.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is GST, GST Registration, GST Return

What is GST? The newly introduced tax which is called GST or Goods and service tax is an indirect tax levied in India on the supply of goods and services and this tax and it is levied at every step in the production process but it means to be refunded to all parties in the various stages of production other than the final consumer. GDT is an indirect tax which is levied on goods as well as services and all the existing state and central indirect taxes are subsumed under the GST . Good And Service Tax (GST) is applicable throughout the country (except Jammu and Kashmir) and it is also referred to as “One Nation One Tax”. A single product is taxed at the same rate in every corner of the country except Jammu & Kashmir this system under. Benefits of GST!                There are some important benefits of GST ü   Elimination of Multiple Taxes: One of the biggest benefits of GST is it eliminates multiple indirect taxes and all the taxes which currently exist will not be i
Post a Comment
Read more

FM Nirmala Sitharaman busy, GST Council meet pushed back to Saturday

The  GST Council  meeting, which would have taken up the issue of slashing of tax rates for electric vehicles, was on Thursday rescheduled for Saturday. Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, the chairman of the Council, was busy with the ongoing Parliament session, officials said. The meeting, which was to be held through a video conferencing, had a single agenda to boost production of electric vehicles (EVs). The agenda included reduction in GST rate from 12 per cent to 5 per cent for electric vehicles and from 18 per cent to 12 per cent for their chargers. It was also to discuss GST exemption on hiring electric buses. All state finance ministers and officials were logged in for 15 minutes for the meeting at 3 pm before being informed of further delay and a possibility of deferment. In fact, a few finance ministers, mostly from Opposition-ruled states, questioned the urgency to call a meeting for a single point agenda. “What was the urgency to call a Council meeting for a
Post a Comment
Read more

GST Notifications, GST Announcements,

There was a lot of outrage recently over two different issues. First was a reduction in monthly GST collection in February 2019 and second was an aspersion over economic growth data. Both these aspersions raised the question of the veracity of economic growth and “vikas” claimed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. All concerns and aspersions raised may not be fully addressed and some of those concerns on economic growth could possibly be fair and relevant. However, we need a detailed discussion on average daily GST collection data to understand one dimension of economic growth and verify whether the economy is on the right track. Indirect tax collection is a direct indicator of economic activity and a tangible measure of growth. Tax collection data also presents a real understanding of how nominal the economy has grown. Tax collection is a direct reflection of an increase in business activity – be it investment or consumption. On the investment part, with an increase in the purchas
Post a Comment
Read more